Is First Trust Value Line Dividend Index Fund (FVD) halal?Not compliant
First Trust Value Line Dividend Index Fund (FVD) is not a Shariah-compliant fund: 46.1% of its weight is in companies that fail the Shariah screen, through their line of business or their debt and cash. 34.9% passes and 19.0% could not be screened.
- Passes 34.9%
- Fails 46.1%
- Not screened 19.0%
Holdings that fail the screen
| Holding | Weight | Why |
|---|
| HZN Bright Horizon Energy Corp | 0.86% | Debt 77.5% of market cap |
| CMCSA Comcast Corporation (Class A) | 0.47% | Debt 96.8% of market cap |
| TMUS T-Mobile US, Inc. | 0.47% | Debt 48.5% of market cap |
| LOW Lowe's Companies, Inc. | 0.46% | Debt 30.3% of market cap |
| AIZ Assurant, Inc. | 0.45% | Excluded activity (Insurance - Property & Casualty) |
| FHI Federated Hermes, Inc. (Class B) | 0.44% | Excluded activity (Asset Management) |
| AVA Avista Corporation |
Frequently asked questions
Is FVD halal?
First Trust Value Line Dividend Index Fund (FVD) is not a Shariah-compliant fund: 46.1% of its weight is in companies that fail the Shariah screen, through their line of business or their debt and cash. 34.9% passes and 19.0% could not be screened.
What share of FVD passes the Shariah screen?
34.9% of the fund's weight (84 of 241 holdings) is in companies that pass; 46.1% (110 holdings) fails; 19.0% (47 lines) could not be screened.
Which FVD holdings are not Shariah compliant?
The largest are HZN (0.86%), CMCSA (0.47%), TMUS (0.47%), LOW (0.46%), AIZ (0.45%), FHI (0.44%), AVA (0.44%), RLI (0.44%), among 110 in all. Banks, insurers, credit and asset managers, alcohol, tobacco and gambling are excluded on their business; the others carry debt or cash above 30% of their market value.
What are halal alternatives to FVD?
Funds with a Shariah mandate screen their holdings and purify their income: SPUS, HLAL, UMMA, SPTE, SPWO. Each has its own page here, with the same holding-by-holding check.
How is FVD screened?
Each holding goes through the halal stock screener's test: interest-bearing debt and cash plus short-term investments each under 30% of market cap (AAOIFI's limits, the strictest of the five published sets), and a line of business that is not excluded. Holdings are as the fund reported them on November 17, 2026; companies listed outside the US, cash, bonds and derivatives are not screened.
Shariah funds checked the same way: Is SPUS halal?, Is HLAL halal?, Is UMMA halal?, Is SPTE halal?, Is SPWO halal?. All halal ETFs compared. Run all five published standards on this fund with the check below.
A mechanical screen of published financial ratios and each company's line of business, not a religious ruling. It does not test income from excluded activities; check with a scholar you trust.